Welcome back to 1910 & Beyond, your regular briefing on the ever-evolving world of appellate law in Houston and beyond. Each post spotlights notable developments from Houston’s two courts of appeals—the First and Fourteenth—as well as from other state and federal appellate courts across Texas and nationwide. From time to time, I also share practical tips on oral and written advocacy. I hope you find these posts useful to your practice and your understanding of what’s happening in Texas appellate law.
To those who have already subscribed, mahalo. If you haven’t yet, I hope you’ll consider joining us!
Opening Statement
Aloha from Honolulu, where I’ll appear later today before the Supreme Court of the State of Hawaiʻi. Among other issues, the case asks whether Hawaiʻi appellate courts should follow the party-presentation principle, under which courts generally decide cases based on the arguments the parties have presented. (I have strong views on that subject, contrary to at least one Fifth Circuit judge, but that isn’t the point of this post.)
If your Tuesday evening is unexpectedly open, the argument begins at 7 p.m. Central and 2 p.m. Hawaiʻi time. You can watch on YouTube or—if you happen to be in Hawaiʻi—on ʻŌlelo 55. (Mom, I finally made it onto TV!)
*
Aloha can mean both hello and goodbye. And on Friday, before leaving for Honolulu, I said goodbye to Justice Kristin Guiney.
Hundreds attended her funeral liturgy. As Reverend Gately joked, it looked like a meeting of the Harris County Bar Association. The mourners also included jurists from across Texas, among them Chief Justice Jimmy Blacklock. Afterward, he said that he simply wanted Justice Guiney’s family and friends to know that the Supreme Court cared. I was touched by his thoughtfulness—especially in the midst of a busy campaign season—and I know others were, too.
Reverend Gately reminded us that the day was meant to celebrate Justice Guiney’s life. And there certainly was much to celebrate. She devoted more than 25 years to public service, first as a prosecutor, then as a district judge, and finally as an appellate justice. She tried or presided over hundreds of jury trials, served people working to rebuild their lives through Star Court, and authored over 225 opinions during her tenure on the First Court. Her time on the First Court was far too short, but long enough for her colleagues to know what a remarkable colleague they had in her.
Those accomplishments, no doubt, tell an important part of her story. But they don’t speak to her life outside the courtroom, especially as a wife and proud mother of two daughters. Nor do they capture what I’ll remember and celebrate most: her friendship, her humor, and the warmth and joy she brought into a room. Those qualities don’t appear on a résumé, and in the grand scheme of a life, they matter far more than jurisprudence. They live on in the people fortunate enough to have known her. I’m grateful to be one of them. Like so many others, I only wish we’d had more years.
Aloha, Justice Guiney. It may be some time, but I’ll see you at the end of the rainbow.
1910
Orders and Opinions
And now, to our local courts here in Houston. While ordinarily I highlight one notable opinion from the First and Fourteenth Courts, this week I feature only one. Then I turn to brief summaries of others worth noting.
Feature
City of Houston v. Savage, No. 01-24-00768-CV (Adams, C.J.; Guiney, Johnson, JJ.): Justice Guiney’s final opinion offers a straightforward but unforgiving lesson in appellate briefing. Rose Savage alleged that she was injured when an escalator at George Bush Intercontinental Airport abruptly stopped and restarted. The City of Houston sought summary judgment based on governmental immunity, but the trial court summarily denied its motion.
On appeal, the City argued that it owed no duty because it had leased the premises to United Airlines and that Savage hadn’t pleaded the requirements applicable to a licensee. But Savage’s summary-judgment response had also requested a continuance for additional discovery concerning who controlled the escalator, and the City’s opening brief didn’t challenge that possible basis for the ruling. Because an appellant must attack every independent ground that could support an unexplained order, the First Court affirmed without reaching the City’s immunity arguments.
Issued the day after Justice Guiney’s death, the opinion became her final contribution to the First Court. Its disciplined analysis and narrow resolution reflect the careful attention to the law, sound judgment, and fairness that her colleagues valued in her work.
N.B.: Before filing an opening brief, identify and address every ground the appellee offered below that could sustain the challenged ruling, especially when the trial court gave no reasons. An unaddressed ground may end the appeal before the court ever reaches the merits.
In Brief
1COA
Rauf v. Manhattan Life Group, Inc., No. 01-23-00671-CV (Adams, C.J.; Guiney, Johnson, JJ.): Affirming in part and reversing in part, the First Court upheld specific performance and attorney’s fees in favor of the buyer but reversed the exemplary-damages award. Legally sufficient evidence supported the fraud findings because the seller’s broker marketed the entire property as available while the seller knew that an undisclosed, long-term lease encumbered it, and the fraud was complete when the buyer entered the sale contract in reliance on that representation. But Section 41.004 bars exemplary damages when the jury awards no damages other than nominal damages, and specific performance doesn’t constitute actual damages.
Solaija Enterprises, LLC v. AmGuard Insurance Co., No. 01-24-00112-CV (Adams, C.J.; Guiney, Johnson, JJ.): Affirming a take-nothing judgment for the insurer, the First Court reaffirmed the harsh consequences that follow when an appellant requests a partial reporter’s record without filing the statement of points or issues required by Rule 34.6(c)(1). Without that statement, the appellate court must presume that the omitted portions support the judgment, rather than that the partial record is complete for the issues presented. Because Solaija omitted all trial testimony, that presumption defeated both its legal-sufficiency challenge and its attempt to establish harmful charge error.
City of Houston v. Guevara, No. 01-24-00820-CV (Caughey, Morgan, Dokupil, JJ.): Reversing and rendering, the First Court held that the City retained governmental immunity because its police sergeant was outside the scope of his employment when the collision occurred. The sergeant’s affidavit established that he was commuting to work, was not yet on duty, was performing no official duties, and was not being paid, rebutting any presumption arising from his use of a City-owned vehicle. Because the plaintiffs offered no contrary evidence, they failed to establish the Tort Claims Act’s motor-vehicle waiver.
Texas RV & Car Care v. Oehlke, No. 01-23-00208-CV (Rivas-Molloy, Guiney, Morgan, JJ.): Reversing and remanding, the First Court held that no evidence showed Texas RV made a misrepresentation or intentionally withheld information that produced the RV’s water damage. Evidence that Texas RV improperly installed the air-conditioning unit or failed to seal holes in the roof might support another theory, but it did not establish the DTPA theory submitted to the jury, and any representations made after the damage occurred couldn’t have caused it. But because the jury also found for the plaintiff on negligence and negligent misrepresentation, the court remanded for a new election of remedies.
Alexander v. The Woodlands Land Development Co. L.P., No. 01-22-00827-CV (Guerra, Gunn, Morgan, JJ.): Affirming summary judgment in a suit by homeowners whose properties flooded during Hurricane Harvey, the First Court declined to recognize a negligence duty owed by a subdivision developer to downstream purchasers because no established law imposed one and foreseeability alone was insufficient. The developer also defeated the negligent-undertaking claim because it exercised reasonable care in the task it actually assumed: retaining a reputable firm to determine the flood-of-record elevation and setting minimum slab elevations six inches above that figure. The engineers and Bowles owed no negligence duty absent privity or another relationship, and the homeowners offered no evidence that they negligently performed their limited undertaking to translate the supplied flood data into slab elevations. Finally, as to Howard Hughes, the homeowners failed to challenge the no-evidence grounds on duty, breach, and causation, independently requiring affirmance.
14COA
Purnell v. 1000 Main, LLC, No. 14-25-00622-CV (Christopher, C.J.; Wise, Jewell, JJ.): Reversing and remanding for a new trial, the Fourteenth Court held that the trial court abused its discretion by denying a continuance and dismissing the plaintiff’s case with prejudice when her attorney had timely designated the trial week for summer vacation. The governing regional and local rules protected counsel from trial and pretrial proceedings during that week, even though the trial setting preceded the vacation designation. Counsel didn’t waive that protection by appearing at the setting after he requested a nonsummer date, moved for a continuance, and objected to the setting.
City of Houston v. Rajendra, No. 14-25-00300-CV (Jewell, Wilson, Boatman, JJ.): Affirming the denial of the City’s Rule 91a motion, the Fourteenth Court held that the plaintiff adequately pleaded the Tort Claims Act’s motor-vehicle waiver by alleging that a garbage-truck driver continued driving as the decedent pursued and banged on the truck, causing him to lose his balance and suffer a fatal head injury. The alleged failure to stop wasn’t too geographically or temporally attenuated from the injury, and the pleadings allowed a reasonable inference that personal injury was foreseeable. The court also treated the City’s purported reply as an amended Rule 91a motion because it first challenged the amended allegations invoking the waiver, thus restarting Rule 91a’s deadlines and making the plaintiff’s later filings timely.
WM Capital Partners 83, LLC v. INOC Properties, LP, No. 14-25-00518-CV (Wise, McLaughlin, Bridges, JJ.): Affirming a take-nothing judgment after a bench trial, the Fourteenth Court held that WM Capital failed to prove a certain balance due on the promissory note following foreclosure. Its payoff statement didn’t explain how the foreclosure proceeds and prior payments were applied, how interest was calculated under agreements employing different rates, or what the listed unpaid fees represented, and its witness neither prepared the statement nor knew the underlying calculations. The trial court could permissibly find that evidence unreliable even though the defendants presented no contrary evidence.
Arguments
1COA
Khoury v. U.S. Bank Trust Nat’l Ass’n, No. 01-24-00985-CV (Rivas-Molloy, Guerra, Gunn, JJ.): Did the trial court err by granting summary judgment upholding a home foreclosure when the parties disputed when the four-year limitations period under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 16.035 began, whether the lender timely exercised its foreclosure rights, and whether equitable tolling extended the limitations period?
Appellants: Ira Joffe, Esq.
Appellees: Alexandria Epps (Ghidotti | Berger)
Argument: October 14 at 1:30 pm
CirclesX Recovery L.L.C. v. BP Energy Co., Nos. 01-24-00963-CV, 01-24-00964-CV (Adams, C.J., Guiney*, Johnson, JJ.):1 Among other issues arising from Winter Storm Uri, did the MDL court err under Rule 91a by dismissing CirclesX Recovery LLC’s claims that natural-gas-market participants interfered with retail utility contracts, created an intentional nuisance, and were unjustly enriched by allegedly restricting the gas supply and driving up energy prices?
Appellant: Allan Kanner (Kanner & Whiteley)
Appellees: Stephen Crain (Bracewell)
Argument: October 20 at 1:30 pm
Hawk Aviation, LLC v. Tavaero Jet Charter Corp., No. 01-25-00501-CV (Adams, C.J., Guiney*, Johnson, JJ.): Among other issues, were Tavaero Jet Charter Corporation’s invoice claims timely under Texas law governing open accounts, and was Floyd C. Wilson personally liable for Hawk Aviation, LLC’s debts under the main-purpose doctrine?
Appellants: Keith Jaasma (Ewing & Jones)
Appellee: Colin Guy (Hoover Slovacek)
Argument: October 20 at 2:30 pm
Frohn v. Shell US Hosting Co., No. 01-24-00571-CV (Caughey, Morgan, Dokupil, JJ.): Did the trial court err by entering a take-nothing judgment on an employee’s claim for unpaid bonus and share awards when the parties dispute whether, under the governing agreements, her departure from Shell was a resignation or a redundancy after her international assignment ended and she declined alternative positions?
Appellant: Colin Guy (Hoover Slovacek)
Appellees: Warren Huang (Norton Rose Fulbright)
Argument: October 22 at 1:30 pm
All arguments can be livestreamed here.
14COA
Elite RE Investments, LLC v. New Phase Investments, LLC, No. 14-25-00946-CV (Wise, Jewell, Wilson, JJ.): Among other issues arising from a failed real-estate venture between two brothers and their LLCs, did the trial court err by imposing an informal fiduciary duty on one brother despite the entities’ arm’s-length agreements, and by allowing one LLC to recover directly for injuries allegedly suffered by the jointly owned company?
Appellants: Rachel Stinson (Wright Close Barger & Guzman)
Appellee: Robert Booth (Mills Shirley)
Argument: October 13 at 2 pm
Lumen v. Harris County, No. 14-25-01096-CV (Wise, McLaughlin, Boatman, JJ.): After this Court previously held that three former Harris County employees raised fact issues on their Texas Whistleblower Act claims, did the trial court err by dismissing those claims based on the preclusive effect of rulings in a separate federal First Amendment case involving different legal standards?
Appellant: Scott Poerschke (The Poerschke Law Firm)
Appellee: Radia Thiagarajan (Office of Harris County Attorney)
Argument: October 14 at 2 pm
In re Harris County Municipal District No. 477, No. 14-26-00034-CV (Jewell, McLaughlin, Antú, JJ.): Did an alternate juror’s participation in deliberations support a new trial, or did Gold Star Realty waive the issue by not objecting before the verdict was announced or the jury discharged?
Relator: Ryan Clinton (Hunton Andrews Kurth)
Real Party in Interest: Charles McFarland (McFarland)
Argument: October 14 at 2:30 pm
Nguyen v. Pusch, No. 14-25-00932-CV (Wilson, Hart, McLaughlin, JJ.): Among other issues arising from a dispute over control of Pusch & Nguyen Law Firm, PLLC, did the trial court abuse its discretion by entering a temporary injunction that restricted the parties’ management, distribution, and trademark rights while they disputed whether Nguyen had been validly expelled from the firm, and by requiring the transfer of contested trademarks before trial?
Appellant: Chi-Hung David Nguyen (The Nguyen Injury Law Firm)
Appellees: Rodney Drinnon (McCathern Houston)
Argument: October 20 at 2 pm
Dominguez v. State, No. 14-25-00324-CR (Hart, McLaughlin, Antú, JJ.): Among other issues, did the trial court violate the defendant’s discovery or confrontation rights by admitting testimony from previously undisclosed toxicologists and a substitute medical examiner?
Appellant: Stanley Schneider (Schneider & McKinney)
Appellee: Ryan Kent (Harris County District Attorney’s Office)
Argument: October 22 at 2 pm
All arguments can be livestreamed here.
& Beyond
With our Houston docket complete, it’s time to board the connecting flight to the islands beyond, beginning in Washington.
SCOTUS
Aloha, Washington. The Supreme Court released no opinions, but it issued a wave of orders on upcoming cases, including yet another involving the midterm elections, and prepared for two more arguments in the new October Term.
Opinions
Merits opinions are months away, but the Court issued two writings on orders—including one concerning a highly publicized execution.
Nelsen v. Pike, No. 26A428 (Sixth Circuit): Should the Court vacate the stay of the execution of a defendant when there is a pending request to reopen a prior judgment denying habeas relief under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b)?
Majority (per curiam): Stay vacated.
Dissent (Sotomayor, J., joined by Kagan and Jackson, JJ): The application should be denied. The defendant’s argument that the question of defects in prior habeas proceedings should be raised under Rule 60(b)—rather than a barred second habeas petition—has yet to be addressed, and the Sixth Circuit should be given the opportunity. The State’s desire to expedite the execution “by a few days or even weeks cannot outweigh” the defendant’s “fundamental interest in her own life.”
Mulkey v. Alabama, No. 25-7499 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama): Are the Sixth and Fourteenth Amendments violated when the trial court publicly sanctions and jails a prospective juror in front of the entire venire panel and fails to conduct an inquiry into how other members of the panel were impacted by the court’s actions?
Order (per curiam): Cert. denied.
Statement Respecting Denial (Sotomayor, J.): As the case comes to us on plain-error review, I concur in the denial of cert. But this case “provides an example of why judges should restrain themselves” from conducting collateral proceedings to the trial in front of a jury. As the record demonstrates, a court’s actions “can have a profoundly negative impact on members of the jury pool” and can undermine voir dire’s critical function of identifying and removing jurors who are not impartial.
Orders
The Court’s long conference resulted in its customary list of lengthy denials, as well as orders GVR’ing seven cases: three based on Hunter v. United States; two based on Louisiana v. Callais; and one each based on Abouammo v. United States and Mullin v. Doe.2
The Court also granted review in several cases:
Department of Homeland Security v. D.V.D., No. 26-426 (First Circuit):3 (1) Did the district court have jurisdiction over claims brought by aliens based on their fear of removal to a third-party country? (2) Did the district court have authority to issue classwide declaratory relief and vacatur? (3) Is the Government’s Guidance on third-country removals unlawful under statutory, constitutional, or regulatory law? And (4) the Government should address “[s]uch other questions that [it] determines are appropriate for the proper disposition of the case.”
Missionaries of St. John, Inc. v. Frederic, No. 25-1311 (Supreme Court of Kentucky): Does a land-use regulation that prohibits a religious institution from building a religious structure on its own property constitute a “substantial burden” on religious exercise under the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA)?
Marschner v. Marschner, No. 25-1349 (Supreme Court of North Dakota): Does the Uniformed Services Former Spouses’ Protection Act (USFSPA) require state courts to refuse to enforce indemnification provisions in divorce settlement agreements?
Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha, No. 26-104 (Second Circuit): Does 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b)(2)(A) mandate the detention pending removal of aliens who are present in the United States without having been admitted?
The Court also called for the views of the Solicitor General in other cases:
Citizens Bank v. Conti, No. 25-1004 (First Circuit), and Cantero v. Bank of America, N.A., No. 25-1313 (Second Circuit), and Flagstar Bank, N.A. v. Kivett, No. 25-1350 (Ninth Circuit): Does the National Bank Act preempt state interest-on-escrow laws purporting to dictate how national banks price their mortgage-loan products?
AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals, L.P. v. Mosaic Health, Inc., No. 25-1070 (Second Circuit): Does Illinois Brick Company v. Illinois apply to claims for lost-profit damages based on indirect purchases or sales that were not made due to an alleged conspiracy? And does the allegation that businesses had an “opportunity to conspire” plausibly suggest an antitrust conspiracy?
United Biologics, LLC v. Amerigroup Tennessee, No. 25-1388 (Sixth Circuit): Does Illinois Brick bar the intended and actual target of a group boycott from recovering lost-profit damages when there is alleged coercion on the target’s customers to stop doing business with the target?
NHK Spring Co. v. Seagate Technology LLC, No. 25-1358 (Ninth Circuit): Are domestic negotiations sufficient to bring foreign injuries from allegedly price-fixing foreign transactions within the reach of the Sherman Act even if those negotiations had no intervening effect on trade or commerce other than that with foreign nations?
Teck Metals Limited v. Tribes of the Colville, No. 26-130 (Ninth Circuit): Does the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA) authorize damages for the felt loss of a cultural connection to natural resources?
Finally, the Court’s emergency docket resulted in several orders:
Federal Communications Commission v. Brown, No. 26A476 (Fourth Circuit): Should the Supreme Court block an order from the Fourth Circuit requiring the Federal Communications Commission to act by a certain date on a challenge to a notice extending favorable advertising rates to political parties and joint fundraising committees?
Order (Roberts, C.J.): Judgment stayed; response ordered.
Strulovitch v. Bain, No. 26A382 (Superior Court of New York): May a court forbid an individual from participating in religious adjudication before a tribunal of his own faith, despite the requirements of his sincerely held religious belief? And may courts compel the retraction of a religious determination issued by clerics of the individual’s faith?
Order (Sotomayor, J.): Stay denied without prejudice upon the exhaustion of available state-court remedies.
Arguments
October 13
Beaird v. United States, No. 25-5343 (Fifth Circuit)4: Does Stinson v. United States still correctly state the rule for the deference that courts must give to the commentary to the United States Sentencing Guidelines?
October 14
Salazar v. Paramount Global, No. 25-459 (Sixth Circuit): Does the phrase “goods or services from a video tape service provider” in the Video Privacy Protection Act refer to all of a video tape service provider’s goods or services or only its audiovisual goods or services?
All arguments can be livestreamed here.
SCOTX
Leaving Washington, we head west (though not yet as far as Hawaiʻi) for a relatively quiet two weeks at our State’s Supreme Court.
Opinions
The Court issued one opinion without oral argument, one GVR, and one opinion related to the denial of a mandamus petition.
Conduent State Healthcare, LLC v. M&M Orthodontics, PA, No. 24-0802 (Third Court) (no oral argument): Did the court of appeals have jurisdiction over a permissive interlocutory appeal based on the denial of a plea to the jurisdiction brought by a private healthcare company?
Opinion (Sullivan, J., for unanimous Court): No. The relevant statutory hook provides for interlocutory appeals over pleas to the jurisdiction brought “by a governmental unit.” The appellant is not a “government unit” but instead a government contractor, and the statute therefore doesn’t permit the interlocutory appeal. Nor does our precedent provide such an expansive reading of “governmental unit.” And the petitioner’s backup argument misreads another statutory provision granting interlocutory appeals on denials of summary-judgment motions based on immunity, because that provision only applies to individuals who assert immunity.
Blanchard Refining Company, LLC v. Industrial Specialists, LLC, No. 26-0118 (First Court) (no oral argument)5: Did the court of appeals err in finding an indemnity agreement was unenforceable based on the express-negligence rule?
Opinion (per curiam): Maybe, but much of the argument turns on the proper application of our opinion in S&B Engineers & Constructors, Ltd. v. Scallon Controls, which was issued after the petition was filed. We accordingly GVR the case for further proceedings in light of that opinion.
In re Pardo, No. 26-0384 (Thirteenth Court): Does Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 592 authorize the arrest or confinement of an uncooperative deponent?
Order (per curiam): Mandamus denied.
Concurrence (Hawkins, J., joined by Young, Sullivan, JJ.): I concur in the denial, but the answer must be no, and if the practice recurs, we should intervene in an appropriate case. Rule 592 is intended to preserve “property” by freezing defendants’ assets to ensure they can satisfy whatever judgment a plaintiff eventually wins. It is facially “incongruous with the seizure of a person,” and we have other Rules that permit courts to take individuals into custody that “come with critical protections to guard against a wrongful deprivation of freedom.”
Orders
Aside from the standard denials, the Court also granted six petitions for review and set one mandamus case for oral argument.
Zurich American Insurance Company v. Burlington Northern and Santa Fe Railway Company, No. 25-0511 (Second Court): Did the court of appeals err in finding that claims brought in myriad lawsuits constitute a single accident or occurrence under the relevant insurance policies? And did it err in placing the burden on Zurich to prove it had no further duty to defend based on exhaustion?
Bailey Cowan Heckaman, PLLC v. Clark, Love & Hutson, G.P., No. 25-0534 (Eleventh Court): Did the court of appeals err in applying the bodily-injury exemption under the Texas Citizen’s Participation Act (TCPA) to a fee dispute between two law firms? And did it err in failing to conduct the three-step, burden-shifting analysis under the TCPA?
Texas Tech University v. Espinoza, No. 25-0762 (Seventh Court): Does a plaintiff’s failure to substitute a proper defendant within thirty days as required by the Texas Tort Claims Act render her initially timely suit untimely?
City of Westworth Village v. Burgess, No. 25-0836 (Second Court): (1) Does a municipality’s condemnation of private property for a park have “a primary purpose of economic development or tax enforcement” based on a contract dictating how the park would be used? (2) Did the court err in failing to apply legislative deference? (3) Did the court err in finding that the determination of a “taking” is a fact question?
Ellis v. Prince, No. 25-0939 (Second Court): Does an unlicensed parent engage in the unauthorized practice of law by representing a minor child as next friend in a personal-injury suit?
WCJ Assets, Ltd. v. U.S. Trinity Bridgeport, LLC, No. 26-0353 (Second Court): Did the court of appeals err in sua sponte finding that trial-court orders lacked decretal language, thereby resolving a case on a procedural defect rather than the merits?
In re Walgreen Company, No. 26-0763 (Eighth Court) (orig. proceeding): Are managers and supervisors liable for failing to prevent or correct another employee’s harassment under the Texas Labor Code?
Arguments
The Court’s next argument session begins November 3.
CA5
Leaving Austin, our appellate itinerary takes us next to New Orleans, where the Fifth Circuit generated enough September reading to fill the flight to Honolulu.
Opinions
Domanic v. Christian Brothers Automotive Corp., No. 25-20486 (Duncan, Oldham, Wilson, JJ.): Does Section 1981 prohibit a Christian-only franchise policy as racial discrimination against a Jewish applicant when the policy distinguishes on religion rather than ancestry?
Majority (Duncan, J., joined by Wilson, J.): No. Affirming summary judgment, the Fifth Circuit held that Section 1981 prohibits discrimination based on Jewish ancestry or ethnicity but does not reach purely religious discrimination. Domanic produced no evidence that the company’s Christian-only policy was a pretext for discrimination against ethnic Jews, and the undisputed evidence showed that its franchisees included ethnic Jews who professed Christianity.
Concurrence in the Judgment (Oldham, J.): No. The ministerial exception had to be addressed at the outset, but the undeveloped record didn’t establish whether franchisees served as messengers or teachers of the company’s faith. Use of the McDonnell Douglas framework is questionable at summary judgment generally and for Section 1981 claims specifically, given Rule 56 and Section 1981’s but-for causation standard.
Frankfort v. Metropolis Technologies, Inc., No. 25-11168 (King, Smith, Ramirez, JJ.): Affirming dismissal of an FDCPA claim on alternative grounds, the Fifth Circuit held that the statute’s originator exclusion applies only when a person both collects debts for another and originated those debts. As a result, the district court erred by applying the exclusion without first determining whether Metropolis collected parking fines for others. But the complaint didn’t plausibly allege that debt collection was Metropolis’s principal purpose or that it regularly collected debts for facility owners. Finally, dismissal with prejudice was proper because the plaintiffs’ bare request to amend didn’t identify facts they would add to cure the pleading defects.
Phillips v. Ethicon Endo-Surgery, Inc., Nos. 25-50116, 25-50308 (Smith, Wiener, Higginson, JJ.): Affirming dismissal with prejudice of two related products-liability suits, the Fifth Circuit held that the plaintiffs’ implied-warranty claim failed because they conceded they had not given presuit notice to the only defendant named in the operative complaint. The district court acted within its discretion by denying leave to amend and dismissing with prejudice because the plaintiffs offered no proposed allegations that would cure the notice defect and indeed conceded amendment would be futile. The dismissal of the second suit on preclusion grounds also stood because the plaintiffs didn’t independently challenge that analysis.
Pittsburgh Logistics Systems, Inc. v. Glen Rose Transportation Management, No. 25-50864 (Stewart, Higginson, Ho, JJ.): Did the trial court abuse its discretion in denying a new trial and post-judgment relief, including based on a purported ex parte meeting between the magistrate judge and a party representative?
Majority (per curiam): No. Affirming, the Fifth Circuit concluded that Pittsburgh Logistics Systems failed to show prejudice from the challenged testimony or record support for disturbing the jury’s verdict. Although ex parte meetings are strongly disfavored and often reversible error, the magistrate judge promptly disclosed the meeting’s contents, the discussion didn’t concern the merits, and Pittsburgh knew of the meeting beforehand but did not object.
Concurrence (Ho, J.): No. Judge Ho agreed that reversal was unwarranted but wrote separately to discuss what he called the judicial “audition trap.” Accusations a judge is shaping decisions to secure a higher office are inherently difficult, if not impossible, to disprove because virtually any judicial action can be reframed as part of an “audition.” Although acknowledging the magistrate judge’s frustration after receiving emails suggesting delays might affect his prospects for future appointment, judges should let their record speak for itself.
Mieco, L.L.C. v. Pioneer Natural Resources USA, Inc., No. 25-11204 (Clement, Oldham, Douglas, JJ.): Affirming judgment for Pioneer after a bench trial, the Fifth Circuit held that Winter Storm Uri prevented full performance under the parties’ natural-gas contract and that Pioneer exercised due diligence by taking reasonable measures before, during, and after the storm. The district court complied with the mandate rule by determining that the storm made performance impracticable and by separately assessing Pioneer’s efforts to prepare for and mitigate its effects. It also acted within its discretion by admitting Pioneer’s expert testimony on industry practice while excluding MIECO’s proposed testimony interpreting contractual terms as impermissible legal conclusions.
Texas Capital Bank v. Government National Mortgage Association, No. 25-10624 (Elrod, C.J.; Willett, Wilson, JJ.): Affirming, the Fifth Circuit held that federal law authorized Ginnie Mae to extinguish a defaulting mortgage issuer’s interests in pooled reverse mortgages, including later-arising, unsecuritized balances known as “tails,” which necessarily eliminated Texas Capital Bank’s derivative lien interests. The bank’s tortious-interference claim was barred by sovereign immunity because it arose from alleged interference with contractual payment rights. The district court also properly declined to consider a distinct arbitrary-and-capricious theory that the bank omitted from its complaint and first raised in opposing dismissal.
Orders
Parish of Cameron v. Devon Energy Production Co., L.P., No. 26-30505 (Smith, Southwick, Wilson, JJ.) (per curiam) (order): Granting a stay pending appeal, the Fifth Circuit held that docketing a Section 1447(d) appeal from a remand order in a federal-officer-removal case automatically stays the remand. Without a stay, continued state-court proceedings could defeat the statutory right to appellate review of the proper forum. Neither transmission of the remand order nor the Anti-Injunction Act barred the stay because the federal courts retained authority over the appealable remand order and the stay was in aid of the appellate court’s jurisdiction.
Evans v. Garza, No. 23-50541 (en banc): Should the en banc court reconsider the denial of a preliminary injunction against enforcement of Texas’s invasive-visual-recording statute based on Evans’s publication of a restroom photograph?
Majority (per curiam): Petition denied by 7 to 10 vote.6
Concurrence (Richman, J.): No. The State has a compelling interest in protecting restroom privacy even when the photographed person is fully clothed and outside a stall, and the statute required an intent to invade privacy. Because Evans could communicate her political position without publishing the photograph, she was unlikely to establish that the statute was facially invalid or unconstitutional as applied.
Dissent (Ho, J.): Yes. The photograph—which didn’t invade privacy—was part of Evans’s political message, and the First Amendment protects images as well as words regardless of whether the speaker’s views are popular. The panel’s approach failed to protect political speech consistently across ideological lines.
Dissent (Oldham, J., joined by Jones, Willett, Ho, Duncan, and Engelhardt, JJ.): Yes. The district attorney curiously sought to moot the case on the eve of possible en banc rehearing by representing that evidence hadn’t been retained, limitations had expired, and Evans’s phone would be returned. While that may have prevented rehearing, it didn’t erase the panel decision or assure future speakers that similar investigations would not recur.
Gakou v. Warden of the Prairieland Detention Center, No. 26-10925 (Smith, Southwick, Douglas, JJ.) (per curiam): Denying an emergency stay of removal to Sierra Leone, the Fifth Circuit concluded that Gakou had no meaningful likelihood of success because 8 U.S.C. § 1252(g) deprived the court of jurisdiction to consider his request. A stay of removal directly challenges the execution of a removal order and therefore falls within the statute’s jurisdictional bar. His challenge to removal to a country other than Senegal also could not support relief because the Supreme Court had permitted third-country removals to continue while reviewing that issue.
Arguments
The Fifth Circuit’s next argument session begins November 2.
15COA
Last stop before we head home: the statewide Fifteenth Court.
Opinion
Drusch v. Borchers, Nos. 15-25-00224-CV, 15-26-00087-CV (Brister, C.J.; Field, Farris, JJ.): Resolving related appeals from two Business Court divisions, the Fifteenth Court first upheld Business Court jurisdiction because the pleaded value of the disputed membership units exceeded the statutory threshold and the dispute concerned ownership interests in an organization. Next, it held that the Business Court erred in denying a motion to compel arbitration, as the parties’ arbitration agreement delegated to the arbitrator whether claims under a separate security agreement fell within the arbitration’s scope. But the court affirmed a temporary injunction preventing further transfer of the disputed membership units because preserving them protected the arbitrator’s jurisdiction and avoided irreparable harm.
Arguments
Nothing on the Fifteenth Court’s calendar until December 10.
Red Light
And with that, we’ve reached the end of this appellate island hop.
As always, I welcome your feedback and suggestions for 1910 & Beyond. Please don’t hesitate to leave a comment or email me with thoughts, topic ideas, or tips on interesting cases.
To the growing number of readers who have subscribed—mahalo. If you haven’t yet, I hope you’ll consider joining—especially at the unbeatable cost of free. And if you know someone who might enjoy this content, I’d be delighted if you passed it along.
Until next time, have a great week—and may the Aloha Spirit follow you back to the mainland.
Thank you to my law firm, Hicks Johnson PLLC, for its support of 1910 & Beyond. Hicks Johnson is a premier trial and appellate boutique with offices in Houston and Chicago, known for delivering successful outcomes in high-stakes, complex litigation. We provide superior results for clients by combining elite legal talent and real courtroom experience with cutting-edge technology and strategic client collaboration.
As of publication, the First Court has not announced a substitute for Justice Guiney in the CirclesX and Hawk Aviation arguments.
The Government filed D.V.D. as a stay application, which the Court granted and also treated as a cert. petition.
The Fifth Circuit’s opinion was issued per curiam from a panel consisting of Judges Richman, Graves, and Douglas.
Chief Justice Adams authored the First Court’s opinion, joined by Justices Morgan and Dokupil.
Judges Jones, Willett, Ho, Duncan, Engelhardt, Oldham, and Wilson voted in favor of en banc rehearing. Chief Judge Elrod and Judges Smith, Stewart, Richman, Southwick, Haynes, Graves, Higginson, Douglas, and Ramirez voted against.














