Welcome back to 1910 & Beyond, your regular briefing on the ever-evolving world of appellate law in Houston and beyond. Each post spotlights notable developments from Houston’s two courts of appeals—the First and Fourteenth—as well as from other state and federal appellate courts across Texas and nationwide, while also sharing practical tips on oral and written advocacy. I hope you find these posts useful to your practice and your understanding of what’s happening in Texas appellate law.
To those who have already subscribed, thank you. If you haven’t yet, I hope you’ll consider joining us!
I’m pleased to continue Questions Presented, a new monthly 1910 & Beyond interview series about the craft of appellate advocacy, viewed from the other side of the bench. In each installment, an appellate judge or justice answers the same ten questions about the path to chambers, what earns an advocate trust on the page, what helps at the lectern, and what lawyers should better understand about the work of appellate judging.
The series takes its inspiration from Howard Bashman’s 20 Questions for the Appellate Judge at How Appealing, adapted for the courts and advocates covered here.
Our next guest is Chief Justice Tracy Christopher of the Fourteenth Court of Appeals. Chief Justice Christopher joined the Fourteenth Court by appointment in 2009 and was elected chief justice in 2020. Before joining the court, she served 15 years as judge of the 295th District Court and practiced for 13 years at Susman Godfrey and Vinson & Elkins. She is board certified in civil trial law and personal-injury trial law and chairs the Supreme Court Advisory Committee.
1910: Path to Chambers
The road to law and the experiences that shape a judge.
1. What first drew you to the law, and which parts of your career most shaped the judge you’ve become?
Our family loved to argue. One brother was a lawyer, one brother was in law school, and my mother wanted to be a lawyer too. I always thought that being a judge would be the best part of the law.
2. Is there a lesson from a mentor, colleague, or advocate that still influences how you approach cases today?
My husband was a practicing lawyer and his experiences with poor judges made me think of what I would do differently.
Statement of the Case
How judges read briefs and what earns trust on the page.
3. When you first open a brief, what are you looking for, and what helps you get oriented quickly?
I love a good table of contents that is substantive.
4. What signals tell you that a brief, and the advocate behind it, can be trusted?
Good citations to the record. If those are missing or wrong, the brief cannot be trusted. When arguing a no-evidence point, you have to address the evidence that is not favorable to you.
5. When the law or the record is unfavorable, what can counsel do to present the strongest credible argument without overstating the case?
If the law is unfavorable, you can argue for a change in the law. If the record is unfavorable, do not make the argument.
At the Lectern
What works in oral argument, what doesn’t, and when it matters.
6. What distinguishes an advocate who merely knows the case from one who knows how to help the court decide it?
An advocate who has worked out what the result is for the case is the most helpful. Is this a remand or a render or an affirm or half-and-half?
7. What can oral argument add to the court’s understanding that even an excellent brief often cannot?
Argument allows a litigant to focus on the law that is most favorable to their position. It should not be used to argue facts.
8. When a question from the bench exposes a weakness in counsel’s position, what does a useful answer sound like?
Acknowledge the weakness but explain why it is not dispositive.
& Beyond: Judge to Counsel
Perspective on the court, the craft, and building an appellate career.
9. What do you wish lawyers, appellate or otherwise, better understood about the work of appellate judging?
Our caseload is high and difficult cases take time. Please forgive us on any delay in getting our opinions out.
10. What advice would you offer lawyers who are trying to find their way into appellate practice or beginning to find their footing in the field?
Get good at one area of the law—is it the charge or summary judgments or preservation of error or even sanctions? Use that to give advice to trial lawyers. If you understand trial-court practice, then you will be more marketable for appellate work.
Red Light
My many thanks to Chief Justice Christopher for joining me for this installment of Questions Presented. I’m looking forward to continuing the conversation with judges from the courts covered by 1910 & Beyond. If you’re a judge who’d like to take part in a future installment, I’d be very glad to hear from you.
To everyone reading and subscribing, thank you. If you haven’t subscribed, I hope you’ll consider joining us. It’s free, and sharing 1910 & Beyond with another appellate-minded reader is always appreciated.
Until next time, have a great week!
Thank you to my law firm, Hicks Johnson PLLC, for its support of 1910 & Beyond. Hicks Johnson is a premier trial and appellate boutique with offices in Houston and Chicago, known for delivering successful outcomes in high-stakes, complex litigation. We provide superior results for clients by combining elite legal talent and real courtroom experience with cutting-edge technology and strategic client collaboration.





Enjoyed the Q&A. Would love to see more of these.